Who may decide
Only an allowlisted editor authenticated by both email and a stable user subject may enter the private workbench. Authentication alone is not editorial authorization, and email alone cannot grant premium or publication access.
Dubaist · Trust layer
Editorial review policy
Editorial review is a recorded control with stable identity, exact scope and auditable decisions; it is not an informal approval or a substitute for evidence rights.
What is reviewed
The editor reviews the exact record version, evidence lineage, required fields, three public locales, rights state, freshness and conflicts. A decision for one record or locale does not approve another.
How a decision is stored
Review, reject, publish, reopen and revoke transitions require a rationale and idempotency key. Compare-and-set status changes and append-only audit records prevent concurrent or silent state changes.
What Editorial review cannot waive
A human cannot turn Missing into a fact, public access into reuse permission, stale data into current data or a coverage set into a recommendation. BUY, HOLD, SELL, targets and portfolio weights require a separate owner investment decision.